[Roosevelt Island's Community Newspaper]
[]
February 4, 1998
A Routine Tram Trip,
Then Chaos, Terror
Over the East River

by Dick Lutz
Additional images courtesy Newschannel 4 and Channel 7 Eyewitness News

An 8:52 a.m. trip.   Tuesday, January 24.   Weather clear.

A RIOC surveillance tape would later show that more than two dozen boarded Aerial Tramway Car No.  1, Manhattan-bound.

No babies in strollers, no children, no wheelchairs.

[Picture] An experienced cabin attendant, Elliot Isaac, veteran of 18 years on the Tramway, secured the straps at the turnstiles, slid the platform barrier gate into place, closed the cabin doors.  Then, at the controls, he did what he had done hundreds of times before to start a trip.

Routine.

Nothing, at the start, to suggest that within minutes there would be a dozen injuries, seconds of chaos and minutes of terror, then news choppers overhead, ambulances, and - in the small way that Roosevelt Island sometimes manages - media attention and history.

Precautions

Weeks before, there had been special Tram trips, pausing over the East [Picture] River while operators of a crane helping with repairs of the Queensboro Bridge set limit switches that offered assurance their long reach, sometimes augmented by estuary tides, would stay out of the path of passing Tram cars.  Arrangements were in place for communication - not directly with cabin attendants, but through supervisors - when the huge Summerville crane would be ranging near the very predictable path of the Tramway's cabins.

Tram workers had noticed, days before, that the crane operator must be lifting limit switches, and there had been complaints and discussion to reinforce safety.

Even then, this was a routine trip.

Even with two maintenance workers on tower number 3, greasing the track ropes, and a supervisor in the booth as required when personnel are potentially at risk - a routine trip.

[Picture]
Courtesy Newschannel 4

Collision

"There was a bang, like an explosion," one passenger says.  "Then we were all on the floor, the cabin swinging wildly.  I thought we were going to go down." The huge boom of the construction crane had hit the bottom left corner of the leading edge of the cabin, and while the 3,000 horsepower motors of the Tramway continued to pull the cabin toward Manhattan - and Cabin No.  2 toward Roosevelt Island - Cabin No.  1 was retarded in its progress while its overhead hanger arm continued to move.  Then, seconds later, hauled clear of the crane, the cabin swung wildly - "so wildly that I thought it would jump off
[Picture]
Newschannel 4
the cables," says an experienced Tramway obsever who has asked to remain unnamed - so wildly that those in the cabin, almost all of whom had been thrown to the floor, elected to stay there even after ordinary impulse told them they might stand again.

Facts

The accident is being investigated by New York State, as required by law, and an official report will ultimately be issued.  But some key facts have been established through conversations with informed observers and those at the scene at the time of the collision:

  • No Console Operator was on duty at the time of the accident.  Though a supervisor was in the console booth because maintenance workers were on the tower, he was not functioning as a Console Operator - not there to monitor the Tram's proximity to the crane.  Console operators were eliminated by RIOC in the Fall of 1997 in an attempt to economize.

  • After the accident, a RIOC spokesperson asserted at first that a Console Operator would not have been able to see the accident, later that there was a Console Operator on duty.  Those familiar with Tramway operation say a Console Operator, functioning in that capacity, would have had a clear view of the accident about to happen.

    [Picture]
    Courtesy Channel 7 Eyewitness News
    [Picture]
    Newschannel 4

  • The automatic limit switches, set up when the crane operation began, were supposed to keep the crane at least 12 feet from the Tram.  There is speculation, as yet unconfirmed, that the limit switches were not restored after an overnight period of crane activity during Tramway down time.

  • A representative of the crane operator has offered to pay medical expenses for at least one injured passenger.

  • Two trips prior to the accident, children and wheelchair-bound riders were aboard.

  • RIOC President Jerome Blue did not go to the scene of the accident.

  • The Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation has made no known attempts to contact the passengers who were injured.

A group of passengers who were injured have gathered to discuss the possibility of legal action (related story).  Patrick Stewart, President of the Roosevelt Island Residents Association, has suggested that a suit against RIOC and RIOC executives might be appropriate.  "We warned them repeatedly," Stewart says, "that elimination of the Console Operators would reduce the safety of the operation."

[Picture]
Newschannel 4

Aftermath

Immediately after the damaged car docked in Manhattan, perhaps a dozen passengers left the station, but some 20 registered their presence on a sheet of paper that Public Safety holds, and eleven were taken to hospitals - at least one on a stretcher, another in a wheelchair, others limping or dazed.

Some injuries drew blood, while others went unnoticed in the excitement, even until the next day when pain presented itself unexpectedly as notice of damage or a strain.

RIOC announced, at first, that Tramway service would be suspended for about a week, then changed the time period to "indefinite" in notices posted on Island kiosks.

RIRA President Stewart and five other Islanders secured a next-day appointment ith RIOC President Blue, who then failed to show up and sent two deputies in his place.  The residents then decided to leave for lack of a RIOC decision-maker who could respond to the crisis actively.

Unlike custom established in all past interruptions of Tramway service, by the weekend RIOC had still not provided alternative transportation for schoolchildren and the disabled.  On Friday, though the State had provided emergency funds for bus service, RIOC President Blue faxed members of the RIOC Board of Directors asking authorization to spend $20,000 of Island public purpose funds for bus service.  (Public purpose funds are earmarked for Island social purposes, not as RIOC emergency money.)

RIRA, which was already planning a Town Meeting on transit in the face of impending subway service cuts and lack of Metrocard transfers from the Tramway, held an emergency Common Council meeting Sunday night, confirming a Town Meeting for tonight.

 

Click for...
Back to issue contents
NYC10044 Contents

LAST   NEXT
Issue list